Skilirium

Document data rules in SBVR

Activity 3 of 8 in Data quality · Occupation: Data quality analyst

The outcome: documents data rules in SBVR and resolves rule anomalies.

Builds on: Select the critical data elements.

Which AI model is best at document data rules in sbvr?

Best result for document data rules in sbvr: gemini-4-argon (92% test score). Best value: claude-haiku-5-5 (88%, within 5 points of the best at $0.006 per run instead of $0.021).

ModelProviderTierTest scoreKnobits mastered (expected)Cost per test run
gemini-4-argonGoogleFlagship92% 89%$0.021
gemini-3.1-pro-preview*GoogleFlagship74% 86%$0.20
gpt-6-astra*OpenAIFlagship89% 94%$0.45
claude-fable-5-1*AnthropicFlagship88% 98%$0.85
gemini-3.8-flash*GoogleMid tier82% 93%$0.045
gpt-6.1-sol*OpenAIMid tier88% 94%$0.077
claude-sonnet-5-5*AnthropicMid tier95% 100%$0.23
gemini-3.5-flash-liteGoogleLow cost32% 43%$0.003
gpt-6-lunaOpenAILow cost82% 78%$0.002
claude-haiku-5-5AnthropicLow cost88% 85%$0.006

* From the earlier benchmark of 2026-10: 10 data-modelling test tasks, 3 runs per task, graded by claude-opus-5-5. These models have not taken the current 123 tasks yet; the two methods differ, so compare their figures with care. They are left out of the “most models” counts and the best-model picks.

Test score: mean rubric score on the test tasks for this activity. Knobits mastered: expected share of the activity's knobits the model masters. Cost: mean API cost of one test run at list prices, half price for answers sent as a batch. Method and caveats.

The 23 knobits of this activity

5 that AI does well, 2 it does partly, and 16 where people still lead.

IDKnobitTypeAI exposure (models mastering)
Q-201Recognises contradicting data rulesSkillPeople still lead 1/4
Q-202Recognises a data rule no valid data can satisfySkillPeople still lead 0/4
Q-203Recognises redundant data rulesSkillPeople still lead 0/4
Q-204Recognises a data rule implied by anotherSkillPeople still lead 0/4
Q-205Recognises overlapping value-set rules on one fact typeSkillPeople still lead 0/4
Q-206Recognises circular derivation rulesSkillPeople still lead 0/4
Q-207Recognises a fact type with clashing modalitiesSkillAI does this partly 2/4
Q-208Recognises one relationship stated as two fact typesSkillPeople still lead 0/4
Q-209Recognises a gap in a partition of casesSkillPeople still lead 0/4
Q-211Recognises a uniqueness rule with no unique key behind itSkillPeople still lead 0/4
Q-212Recognises a rule assigned to a missing data quality checkSkillPeople still lead 0/4
Q-214Recognises a data-update rule with no enforcing or detecting mechanismSkillPeople still lead 0/4
Q-215Recognises an activity or party rule claimed as a data ruleSkillAI does this well 3/4
Q-216Recognises an ambiguous pronoun in a rule statementSkillPeople still lead 0/4
Q-217Recognises mixed and-or without precedence in a ruleSkillPeople still lead 0/4
Q-218Recognises a cardinality rule stated from one end onlySkillPeople still lead 0/4
Q-219Recognises a definitional rule filed as operativeSkillPeople still lead 1/4
Q-220Recognises an operative rule filed as definitionalSkillPeople still lead 1/4
Q-252Explains alethic and deontic modality of rulesKnowledgeAI does this well 3/4
Q-253Explains logical relations between rulesKnowledgeAI does this well 3/4
Q-254Explains derivation rules and their dependenciesKnowledgeAI does this well 3/4
Q-258Explains partitions of a concept into casesKnowledgeAI does this well 3/4
Q-237Resolves contradicting rules by adding the missing conditionSkillAI does this partly 2/4